Facing Facebook – The Business Of Belief

What business is Meta really in?

It’s easy to say “advertising.”
But that answer feels incomplete.
Too simple for a platform that claims to connect billions and shape culture.
Too small for a company projecting $16 billion this year from ads it classifies as scams or fraudulent.
Too basic for a company pledging $600 billion for investment in AI infrastructure in the U.S. alone.

Allegedly the platform runs 15 billion scam ads a day.

This is being reported by Reuters: Meta is earning a fortune on a deluge of fraudulent ads, documents show.
From the article: “A May 2025 presentation by its safety staff estimated that the company’s platforms were involved in a third of all successful scams in the U.S. Meta also acknowledged in other internal documents that some of its main competitors were doing a better job at weeding out fraud on their platforms.”
Is that just a glitch… or it that scale?

And what kind of business is that?

If Meta’s mission is to give people the power to build community and bring the world closer together, how does this serve that?
How do you bring people closer when you’ve become a middleman between trust and deception?
Because at its core, Meta doesn’t sell ads.

Meta sells belief… a story.

Belief that your community is authentic.
Belief that the people and brands around you are who they say they are.
Belief that what you see is real life.
Belief that you are better off being connected in these social media platforms than not.

What happens when that belief fractures?

When a user clicks on a fake product or loses money to a scam, something must break that no algorithm can patch?
And yet if you look at their quarterly earnings, the business keeps humming.
Because the metric that matters isn’t trust (the story).
It’s time (the reality).

Minutes spent… clicks made… engagement recorded.

It’s one thing when you don’t have the technology to moderate these challenges.
It’s quite another when you have the technology that’s pointing you to the exact root of the problem and not much happens after that.
Because the results of these scams aren’t just tolerated, they become a business model… one that comes with the gift of data.
“To advertise on Meta’s platforms, a business has to compete in an online auction. Before the bidding, the company’s automated systems calculate the odds that an advertiser is engaged in fraud. Under Meta’s new policy, likely scammers who fall below Meta’s threshold for removal would have to pay more to win an auction. Documents from last summer called such ‘penalty bids’ a centerpiece of Meta’s efforts to reduce scams.”
Every deceptive ad still teaches the system something about what a user will fall for next.
Also from the article: “…safety staffers estimated that Facebook and Instagram users each week were filing about 100,000 valid reports of fraudsters messaging them, the document says. But Meta ignored or incorrectly rejected 96% of them.”

How long can that last?

What happens to a platform that lets this ride?
What happens when the calculus works out to pay fines because those will be less than the revenue earned?
Do users return after they’ve been burned?
Do they keep scrolling, or do they quietly leave the room?

The irony is almost poetic.

A company built on connecting people now profits most when it can’t tell who’s real…
And can survive when real people can’t stomach to stay, but there are millions of other users who aren’t paying attention.
And in Meta’s calculus, attention (even negative) still pays.

That’s the quiet risk.

A social network drifting into a social experiment.
A global marketplace where the inventory isn’t products or ads… it’s trust.
From a business standpoint, this may work for a while.
Scams scale faster than sincerity.
Fraud converts quicker than friendship.
But the long-term economics must be brutal.
Every scam erodes the core asset Meta was built on… the belief that connection has value.

So the question isn’t whether Meta can make money from this.

It’s whether it still remembers why it wanted to.
Because if connection no longer builds belief…
Then what’s Meta’s business model, really?
Attention can fund a company.

But only belief can sustain it.

This is what Elias Makos and I discussed on CJAD 800 AM.

Before you go… ThinkersOne is a new way for organizations to buy bite-sized and personalized thought leadership video content (live and recorded) from the best Thinkers in the world. If you’re looking to add excitement and big smarts to your meetings, corporate events, company off-sites, “lunch & learns” and beyond, check it out.